Wake up with a Smile

Join our newsletter

Separated Cat Brothers Reunited When Owners Fall In Love On Tinder.

Every now and again, people will uncover some pretty uncanny coincidences when they first start dating – they were born at the same hospital, they were classmates in preschool, or they received heart transplants on the same day at the same hospital.

Brian Herrera and Cathleen Cavin both live in California’s Bay Area, and they were born just two months apart in the same hospital. That’s a coincidence for sure, as is the fact that they’ve both lived in the same cities and attended some of the same concerts. But all those coincidences combined don’t measure up to the one they discovered on their first date in the summer of 2016.

cathleen and brian

But first, some background. Two years earlier, in the summer of 2014, Cathleen and her young daughter, Cali, had their hearts set on adopting two ginger kittens, brothers who were from a litter of six and placed in the same foster home. But their landlord would only allow one cat, so they adopted just one and named him Ozzie. For the first couple weeks at his new home, he cried out piteously, upset, Cali believed, because he missed his brother.

butter and ozzie kittens

“I made a really stupid promise,” Cathleen admits. “I told my daughter I would look for the cat and try to find his brother. I kept saying, ‘I’m going to find him.’â€

Now let’s fast forward to the spring of 2015, when Cathleen, a single mom, and Brian Herrera, a single dad, met on Tinder. She wasn’t especially interested in the beginning, and more than a year went by before they had their first date, in June 2016. After dinner, they went back to his place, and there, out of the corner of her eye, Cathleen spotted an eerily familiar face. A ginger-and-white face with long, white whiskers and sultry, yellow eyes.

I start looking at the cat, and I’m like, “That’s my cat. You have my cat.” And he’s like, “No, that’s my cat.” So he thought I was some crazy cat lady, and I said, “No, I promise you. Come over to my house.”


You guessed it: This fuzzy doppelganger was Ozzie’s brother, now named Butter! You’d think Cathleen and Brian would’ve immediately set up a reunion, but maybe they wanted to make sure things would work out between them before introducing their respective family members. These long-lost siblings finally met on Valentine’s Day 2017, about a month before Cathleen and Cali moved in with Brian and his own young daughter…


We’ve heard of some pretty big coincidences in our time, but it appears fate had to give one final push to finally get these two families together! And that promise Cathleen made to Cali to find Ozzie’s brother? Hey, it took a few years, but a promise is a promise.

What kind of crazy coincidences brought you and your significant other together? Let us know in the comments, and share if you agree life has a way of working things out.

Want to be happier in just 5 minutes a day? Sign up for Morning Smile and join over 455,000+ people who start each day with good news.